How to appeal an IVF insurance denial in Ohio
Ohio has no IVF mandate. HMO plans must include medically necessary infertility services (diagnosis and corrective procedures) as a 'basic health care service', but IVF, IUI, and fertility drugs are not required.
How to appeal a denial
- Internal appeal — you have 180 days from the denial to file. The plan must decide within 30 days (before service) or 60 days (after service); 72 hours if urgent.
- External review — available for at least 4 months after the final internal denial, for medical-necessity and "experimental" denials (PGT-A, ICSI, step therapy). An independent reviewer decides within 45 days. Contractual exclusions are not eligible for external review — those go to the regulator as a complaint.
- Regulator — Ohio Department of Insurance. Ohio external review (ORC § 3922) via independent review organization File a complaint. Copy the regulator on every appeal letter; clinics report it speeds things up.
If your plan is self-funded, skip the state regulator: your appeal runs under ERISA and complaints go to the U.S. Department of Labor's Employee Benefits Security Administration.
Common denial reasons and what to argue
- Step therapy / prior-treatment requirements — check your plan's own Summary Plan Description or clinical policy for its step-therapy criteria and ask the payer for its bypass criteria (age 38+, tubal factor, stage III–IV endometriosis, severe male factor are common).
- Benefit scope — Ohio's law requires coverage of infertility diagnosis only, and only for HMO plans. Check whether the denial is actually outside what the law (or your plan, if it goes further) promises, versus a processing error.
- 'Experimental' (PGT-A, ERA, ICSI without male factor) — eligible for external review; ask the clinic for a medical-necessity letter. Success is limited for PGT-A.
- Medication routing — many denials are the wrong pharmacy or a missing prior auth, not a coverage decision. Ask the specialty pharmacy to re-run with prior auth.
- AI-only review — several states now bar insurers from denying on medical necessity without a physician's individualized review; ask in writing whether AI was the sole basis.